RolePlay onLine RPoL Logo

, welcome to Community Chat

19:12, 19th April 2024 (GMT+0)

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Posted by GreenTongue
GreenTongue
member, 1018 posts
Game Archaeologist
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 17:27
  • msg #1

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Over time my tastes have shifted from highly detailed mechanics with RuneQuest to more abstract like Savage Worlds.

Never was a huge fan of "High Fantasy" but I've found that if a setting isn't closer to Harn than to Dreamlands, I'm much less interested. This has become more so over time.

I want to try games like Dungeon World or something Fate based and yet I have a hard time getting into them.

Pathfinder was a non-starter.

Is it age or just the tendency you fall into a comfortable rut?

Do people age out of RPGs either from having less tolerance for "new" or from being left behind as what everyone else is interested in changes and few if any players remain for "old stuff"?

I'm just inflexible and don't realize it any more?
DBCowboy
member, 71 posts
Played rpgs since about
'81 (D&D Basic ed)
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 17:32
  • msg #2

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Tastes change, not a big deal.  I'm less interested in crunch these days, so 2d20/Savage Worlds/Dungeon World all working better for me.

Best thing about RPGs is the variety in both systems and settings.
donsr
member, 2374 posts
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 17:34
  • msg #3

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

 I was always  more RP focused  then numbers...used the numbers  to  ste a 'base' then Play RP of that.

 I use my own system that players  can build a character, while  concentrating on RP.

 I guess the  anser is..you're never  too old, you just  tend to focus on what part of the games you like.
tmagann
member, 746 posts
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 17:39
  • msg #4

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

I've been playing over 40 years, and I still like a bit of detail in my mechanics. Truthfully, D&D5 is a bit fuzzier on rules than I'd like, and I miss Rolemaster (yes, I realize there is a version still around, but no one really likes that much detail these days).

About the best detail oriented game I can find is Gurps, which is also an old favorite, but it, too, seems to be falling out of favor, juts more slowly.

I don't think it's age so much as a general trend in game rules being published. More are coming out with less detailed mech than used to be usual, and folks gets used to what is available to play, coloring their preferences by resetting what they are familiar with.
Piestar
member, 984 posts
once upon a time...
...there was a little pie
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 17:41
  • msg #5

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Hard to tell, but I feel like maybe age impacts things. I know I couldn't play for as long as I used to, more than three or four hours at tabletop would probably become physically uncomfortable for my sixty year old self, when we would play for far longer than that when I was young. RPoL is great for me in that regard.
nalling
member, 3 posts
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 17:55
  • msg #6

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

I haven't GMed long, and I have little experience with multiple game systems, so I really shouldn't be opening my mouth here...

Having said that, allow me to open my mouth here...

I GM a GURPS game, and some players like diving into the rules to the point where my head spins and I just have to assume they know what they're talking about more than I do (which is absolutely the case) and some just like to RP and we toss a roll in there once in a while to keep it spicy.

I gravitated toward GURPS for the fact that it's a wide-open playing field and the type of game you want to play with it is up to you, which in fact is why I would hesitate to classify what kind of game this thing has morphed into.

I have a "good" necromancer riding around a giant elephant skeleton, I have another player with an Ultra Tech AI body modification solving crimes. So... eh.

*shrug*

I like seeing what my players decide to get into once they're unleashed. It's been a riot, for me at least. I can't speak for them.

As for how old is too old?

I hope to be muddling through obscure rules, and making crap up as I go, minutes before being planted.
engine
member, 858 posts
There's a brain alright
but it's made out of meat
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 18:00
  • msg #7

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

In reply to GreenTongue (msg # 1):

I had a DM who was an older person and was running games pretty much up until their health prevented them.

But your question seems to be about the ability to have interest in new things, which I don't see as a key aspect of being involved with the hobby. Some people get into one game and just stick with that forever. And why not?

I realized years ago that I would never have a chance to really run or even try most of the systems I'm interested in. Some I've had a chance to try, but they didn't grab me enough to put the effort into arranging further games.

When a game offers intetesting ideas that I can separate from the mechanics, I'll sometimes bring them into the system I prefer. I've done that with Fate, Dungeon World and Traveller.

I am starting to feel rather left behind, but I'm okay with that. I don't care for some of the newer games I'm seeing, but I don't have anything much against them or their players, as long as their players don't look down on me.
evileeyore
member, 555 posts
GURPS GM and Player
Joined 20150819
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 18:24
  • msg #8

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

DBCowboy:
Tastes change, not a big deal.

Exactly.  I have a friend who still plays oD&D (1974), and he's like a million and half years old.  I have other friends who've slowely switched to narrative systems, some who started in narrative and have switched to D&D, etc.

Me?  I'm still on my GURPS kick and always will be, but I also enjoy other systems.  For me it's mostly the people, if it's a good group I'll even choke down D&D.
This message was last edited by the user at 18:25, Mon 04 Oct 2021.
Cygnia
member, 305 posts
Amoral Paladin
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 18:25
  • msg #9

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

I promise you this, I will be GMing at the hospice if I end up there.
evileeyore
member, 556 posts
GURPS GM and Player
Joined 20150819
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 18:28
  • msg #10

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Cygnia:
I promise you this, I will be GMing at the hospice if I end up there.

I'll be rolling them bones in the grave comrade.
Mad Mick
member, 1001 posts
GURPS beyond measure,
outlander
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 20:34
  • msg #11

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Funny how some of the older geezers in this thread mention GURPS. =)

I've played with GMs in their 60s. I think the answer is similar to how old people think is too old to play video games. I've seen gaming rigs people build when they're in nursing homes. RPGs are great for keeping the mind active.

A quick search on Google Scholar shows a ton of articles on video games and Alzheimer's/cognition. I'd think RPGs would be ideal for helping people stay engaged mentally.
DrTachyon
member, 97 posts
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 20:40
  • msg #12

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

I'm 59 and I'm still actively GMing and playing TTRPGs. Granted my tastes have changed over the years. I'm more into narrative/story games now a days (like City of Mist, Powered by the Apocalypse Games, etc.). I cut my teeth on D&D, Shadowrun, Call of Cthulhu, GURPS, Savage Worlds and other simulationist / crunchy games. While I had a lot of fun with those older games, I'm more drawn to games that help create more of a TV/Movie feel where we're in a writer's room creating a kick ass show (yes, I know this can be achieved with older games, but the newer ones tend to be designed with this ethos in mind and really support that kind of gaming).

Bottom line - you're never too old to game!
phoenix9lives
member, 1071 posts
GENE POLICE!  YOU!
GET OUTTA THE POOL!
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 20:41
  • msg #13

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

You are only too old to play when they have to pry your dice from your cold, dead hand.  I've been involved in RPGs since the early 1980s.
Piestar
member, 985 posts
once upon a time...
...there was a little pie
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 20:42
  • msg #14

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

In reply to Mad Mick (msg # 11):

I think there is a natural tendency to think that what old people did when we were young is what is natural for old people to do, but I suspect each generations old people do whatever they did when they were young. What people consider, for example, old people clothes is what those people wore when they were in their prime. Gaming is for old people, if that is what they did when they were younger, I suspect.
darknash
member, 166 posts
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 22:07
  • msg #15

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

In reply to GreenTongue (msg # 1):

To Old? when you die.

Its okay for your tastes to change.
evileeyore
member, 557 posts
GURPS GM and Player
Joined 20150819
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 22:45
  • msg #16

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Mad Mick:
Funny how some of the older geezers in this thread mention GURPS. =)

There was a strong realism/crunch push/backlash in the mid-late 80s, most GURPS enthusiasts I know picked up the habit around then.


Granted I've met a lot of yougner GURPS players here on RPoL who picked up the GURPS habit with DF/RPG in the last decade, they like the flexibility of GURPS with the flavor/genre of Dungeon Fantasy (D&D's "Orc and Pie" and "Back To The Dungeon" ethos).
deadtotheworld22
member, 149 posts
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 23:01
  • msg #17

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

I suspect part of it is how much you have an interest in looking at new systems as opposed to keeping to the ones you know.

We all had a system which got us hooked (for me, it was NWOD), and you're less inclined to keep looking for new things when you're satisfied, so once you have a core set of systems and variants, you're probably going to focus on expanding your collection within that niche rather than buying everything new on the market.

In the meantime, everyone's out there creating new things and finding new avenues for profitability, so when you jump back in to new things ten years later, you're seeing the results of ten years of development and trends that may have completely passed you by.

To put it in a different context, if you stopped playing shooters in 2010 and came back now, would you necessarily jump into something like Fortnite or PUBG given how much the genre had changed since then? (Don't read too much into that example, it came straight off the cuff and I'm sure it's not as good as my brain thinks it is)

At the same time, a lot of RPG companies are releasing (at least in part) for a new, arguably wider generation of players with different demographics, interests, levels of experience, attention thresholds and amounts of free time. On the whole, that's a great thing, but it's just another thing which might mean you're less interested in going through the rigmarole of trying to learn a new system which you might hate, when there's a system or three in the background that you know you love.

So, how old is too old to play? No such thing.

How old is too old to pick up new systems on your own? I suspect that's more down to veterancy than age - I've been doing it now for 13 years, and I can't honestly say that I've got the enthusiasm to try a massively new system now that I might have done five years ago.
Heath
member, 2991 posts
If my opinion changes,
The answer is still 42.
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 23:31
  • msg #18

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

I'm so glad I'm not the only one who has been playing for over 40 years and still has an inexplicable love of the game that brings out the creative kid in me.
donsr
member, 2375 posts
Mon 4 Oct 2021
at 23:46
  • msg #19

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

My brother and I started in the  mid  70's playing Avalon Hill  war games... we tried OD&D..but didn't like it, got into   Metagaming CO's  Melee and Wizards..then its  advanced versions...( tactical  RP with hex board)

 2e  and E3 got us interested in D&D again, but then i got  computer   D&D games ( still have them, that i can't use!)

 I traveled   sites for years..EZboards were hacked  and died..and I found this place...after a few years  as only a player, i started  my own games, using my own system.

 I backed  Stevejacksons ,  new release if ITL-Melee/Wizards..mostly out of  'old time sake'...in the end?... I do all my RP here.

 I said it, others  said it...you're never too old...its  a Genre, its liie 'being too old to watch a sci-fi movie"...or Too old to watch sports"//there is  no 'too old'
facemaker329
member, 7363 posts
Gaming for over 40
years, and counting!
Tue 5 Oct 2021
at 02:35
  • msg #20

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

I'll join the chorus of 'No such thing as too old'.  I was introduced to RPGs in junior high, spent junior high and high school playing D&D/AD&D.  After I got out of high school, I kind of tired of the D&D focus on 'kill the monsters and collect the gold'.  My younger brother introduced me to a new GM (who went on to become one of my closest friends), who was playing his own home-brewed fantasy system that was part Chaosium's Basic Role-Playing system, part FASA's Star Trek RPG (I don't remember the name...it wasn't Starfleet Battles, as that was more akin to Battletech...but it could be used in parallel with Starfleet Battles if you wanted to make a larger, expanded campaign), and a few bits and pieces he spliced on out of his own imagination.  I had all but given up on role-playing, prior to that, and he totally reinvigorated my interest in it.

I've played a lot of different games since then...WEG's Star Wars, a few different editions of Shadowrun, tried getting back into D&D a couple of times (it just never clicked again for me), Palladium's fantasy system, RIFTS, GURPS, OWOD, etc...the ones that I always enjoyed were the ones where the GM was more focused on the role-playing and storytelling than the crunchy parts.  I've been in a few games on here that were, technically, running under some kind of rules system...the GM rolled the dice as appropriate so the game looked, from the outside, kind of like a freeform game (players said what they wanted to do, the GM decided if a roll was warranted and--if needed--rolled it, and then posted the reactions to the players' actions, so we as players never had to worry about dice) and they were among my favorites.

As I've gotten older, however, I've found that I have less time available to devote to leisure activities like RPGs...so, I tend to stick to systems that I already know well, unless the setting of the game so intrigues me that I decide it's worth laboring through figuring out a new system (and I am infinitely grateful to those GMs who have held my hand and coached me through getting adjusted to a new system!)  I don't do any table-top gaming anymore because, for me, it was as much or more about the chemistry of the people involved than it was the game, and now that I live an hour or more away from any of my old gaming friends, I don't know anyone that I have that same kind of chemistry with.  I don't necessarily have that kind of chemistry in most of my games on here, but since I don't have direct interaction with the other players, I can fake it (or by the time I've typed up the snarky comeback to something they've done or said, I've had time to consider whether the backlash will be worth enduring and the answer is always 'no', so I delete it).  I have good enough chemistry with enough of the other players that I stick around...and, occasionally, I stumble into a game where everything clicks with everybody and I absolutely love the game and everything about it (those are usually the games that end up with the GM having to discontinue things because RL has reared its ugly head and demanded their attention elsewhere.)

But as long as I can find people that I enjoy interacting with, rules that I can make sense of, and a setting that engages my imagination, I'll be gaming until my pilot light goes out forever.
Yaztromo
supporter, 453 posts
Tue 5 Oct 2021
at 21:37
  • msg #21

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

As your priorities change, so what you look for when roleplaying changes. Similarly, I moved from more complex and detailed rulesets to simpler and ruling-based systems, that allow you to start playing within 5 minutes (no more "session zeros"). Similarly, I moved from very long adventures to "one off" adventures that can be run in a single session.
That's the style of gaming that in this moment fits better my personal situation and my requirements.
Maybe in the future this will change again.
Piestar
member, 986 posts
once upon a time...
...there was a little pie
Tue 5 Oct 2021
at 21:41
  • msg #22

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

I don't know how me-specific this is, but I do find as I grow older that it is harder to find people whose play style is compatible with mine.

That might have something to do with the fact that I have moved a lot over the year, no life-long friends, or even high-school friends any more.

Then again maybe it's me, maybe I get pickier with age, no clue.
donsr
member, 2376 posts
Tue 5 Oct 2021
at 22:08
  • msg #23

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

  its the friends....some get married and there is no room for gaming, outside of Vid Games?... I havepeople i play football with every sunday moring , all year round, NONE..of them would be RP gamers..half  are Video gamers..

 most all old  enough to be my kids and graandkis, so  'going over the old guys house'..or  ;'having the old guy come over' isn't an option...

 I like it in here... I have a good  community in my games, ...and in the games i play in, i have some  friends as well..that's good  enough for me, at the tail end of my run.
silverelf
member, 275 posts
Tue 5 Oct 2021
at 22:10
  • msg #24

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Assume I will still be playing RPGs in Isis's Waiting Room.
Heath
member, 2992 posts
If my opinion changes,
The answer is still 42.
Wed 6 Oct 2021
at 00:45
  • msg #25

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

In reply to Piestar (msg # 22):

This is very true, but there's also a certain sense of awesomeness when you can share the games with your children.
Piestar
member, 987 posts
once upon a time...
...there was a little pie
Wed 6 Oct 2021
at 00:48
  • msg #26

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

In reply to Heath (msg # 25):

Don't have any, sadly. I imagine that would be fun.
donsr
member, 2377 posts
Wed 6 Oct 2021
at 00:55
  • msg #27

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

 all my kids started playing, because they saw me reading books and painting Miniatures..i taught them  the  Melee/wizard games, and they dabbled in D&D. But the  Computer  and Console  D&D...and   'like-type' games got thier  attention
ladysharlyne
subscriber, 3202 posts
Member before Oct 2005
THE GLASS IS HALF FULL
Thu 7 Oct 2021
at 22:47
  • msg #28

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Well now we heard from system gamers and what about us old Freeform writers,  As I look back over the years, since early 70s, I found my niche in Freeform writing and I am 67.  I have written/played with players older than me.  The bonds of friendships I have made here are priceless.

I would love to have written books but what are your chances of getting published?  But yet when you spin a tale with others it’s great enjoyment and satisfaction in seeing others enjoy writing with me.  Yes, I am a GM of many genres and this brings me to my answer to the question ‘ I will write as long as my mind keeps being creative.’  I feel that any kind of gaming is great exercise to keep the mind alive.  So when they lay me to rest give me paper and pen,  Any kind of gaming is usually healthy form of hobby.
Silverlock
member, 127 posts
Fri 8 Oct 2021
at 21:49
  • msg #29

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

68 and still running.  And I went to Origins.  And I wasn't the oldest one there, not by a long shot
Gaffer
member, 1705 posts
Ocoee FL
45 yrs of RPGs
Fri 8 Oct 2021
at 23:52
  • msg #30

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Dead. Dead is too old for RPGs.

Probably.
Hunter
member, 1678 posts
Captain Oblivious!
Lurker
Sat 9 Oct 2021
at 00:00
  • msg #31

Re: How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Gaffer:
Dead. Dead is too old for RPGs.

Probably.


I was going to say "when you can't roll the dice anymore".   But you can always get a cute nurse to do that for you.   ^_^
Gaffer
member, 1706 posts
Ocoee FL
45 yrs of RPGs
Sat 9 Oct 2021
at 01:04
  • msg #32

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

In reply to Silverlock (msg # 29):

One thing and another, I haven’t been to Origins for three years. When I go in 2022, I hope to be running Call of Cthulhu events and I’ll be 73.
phoenix9lives
member, 1072 posts
GENE POLICE!  YOU!
GET OUTTA THE POOL!
Sat 9 Oct 2021
at 01:15
  • msg #33

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

I hope to still be gaming when I get that age.
NowhereMan
member, 456 posts
Sat 9 Oct 2021
at 05:27
  • msg #34

Re: How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

In reply to Hunter (msg # 31):

We had a quadriplegic guy in one of my gaming groups. He had big ol' dice he could kinda-sorta roll some of the time, but either his caretaker or one of the other players would handle it if he couldn't. So forget old, you could probably be one of those heads-in-a-jar from Futurama and still game if you were so inclined.

And speaking of cute nurses, the guy is a regular Casanova with the ladies. Never seen anything like it.
Silverlock
member, 128 posts
Sat 9 Oct 2021
at 20:49
  • msg #35

How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

In reply to Gaffer (msg # 32):

It was a bit rough this year, the pandemic being what it was; most (or all) of the content will be online for events registration.  The convention staff worked hard to make it all happen, very nice people.  My advice is: get a hotel CLOSE to the Convention Center, which is under construction right now.

I would be happy to play in your game, Gaffer, I hope I can secure a seat for it.  Let us all game on !
Brianna
member, 2245 posts
Sun 10 Oct 2021
at 00:01
  • msg #36

Re: How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

In reply to NowhereMan (msg # 34):

When I used to go to GenCon, there were always a number of severely disabled players.  Think about how someone who can only move his wheelchair by blowing into a straw must enjoy playing characters that have the mobility he doesn't.  Hey, even I liked playing with strength, dexterity, etc that I could never aspire to in real life!
Mahatatain
member, 245 posts
Sun 10 Oct 2021
at 17:27
  • msg #37

Re: How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

Heath:
I'm so glad I'm not the only one who has been playing for over 40 years and still has an inexplicable love of the game that brings out the creative kid in me.

39 years as a role player myself and still counting.

I can't imagine that I'll ever "grow up" and stop playing.
donsr
member, 2381 posts
Sun 10 Oct 2021
at 17:45
  • msg #38

Re: How Old is Too Old to Play RPGs?

the bottom line is this?...

 I play football at 66... i stopped golfing long time ago, and Bowling..Softball went  before that.

 I play Video games, and  i Game in here...

 some folks play cards... some  throw darts...Gaming isn't any different, People who can't wrap their  head  around  RP games, , are normally folks who smash beer cans off thier head.

so what is the answer?  Many of you have said it... there is no  'too old',  you're either  still 'in to it' or you're not.
Sign In