OOC
And the first player drops out.
Apparently not being allowed to invent cigars as part of a background while another party in the same setting is only just in the area they were invented is an issue. Well, that and making a ruling he didn't agree with and refusing to do it his way simply because he said the game designer said so.
Folks, fi you want to invent something, do it in game. there are rules for it, more or less. Mostly less, but I can fake it. Also, you can't just pull things out of your pocket you haven't bought because it's good for your personal story. Spend the gold.
If you don't like how I interpret your favorite rule, consider the difference a House rule if I refuse to change to your way of thinking, please. I'm not unreasonable, but this edition has way too many grey areas, and I may not always come down on your side. After nearly 10 years of this I think I have a fair grasp on how the grey areas are generally treated, but I do get it wrong on occasion. And I'm expecting to a fair bit in this game, given the rather larger amount of grey than usual.
.