In reply to Leyna Noc (msg # 95):
So yeah, this is indeed an issue that's not easily tackled. On one hand, I do want to encourage folks to make rolls proactively to keep the pace of the action moving. On the other hand, not everyone -that is, mostly folks that are still learning the system- can't be held to that expectation.
Thus, I propose that yes, you can roll if you believe a roll is warranted. You can do your best to assume the proper Attribute and Skill combinations. This would have to be combined with a description of how your character is doing the thing; maybe even with an OOC clause to clarify what you intend. However, in doing so you have to accept that I may have to adjust the DC for the action accordingly. This system is intended to be flexible, after all, but narratively speaking there is a difference when, for example, Rowing using Constitution with Exert verses Strength with Sailing.
There's also a fine line that can be misinterpreted when a PC is creatively describing the result of a roll versus when the GM describes the results. Again, I like to give the option to the player and the GM should only intervene when necessary. But understand that intervention may sometimes mean retconning.
Secret rolls (such as knowledge, perception, and the like) are also especially tricky. In such cases, I'd prefer if there was a way to roll secretly so only the GM can see the result. If you make a roll that should have been secret, I'll likely re-roll such things for you.
Lastly, remember that not everything requires a roll, and every time you roll for a task that could be failed, there's a possibility for consequences. This is especially true for tasks that relate directly to your background, ancestry, class, etc. If you feel that your character should know how to do something automatically that might normally require a roll, you can make the roll just to be safe but also remind me why your character should just simply succeed.
TLDR: - Please go ahead and make your own rolls if you feel comfortable doing so.
- Please understand that I may have to retcon sometimes.
- Please continue to ask questions as necessary. I do try to answer expediently.
This message was last edited by the GM at 02:07, Sat 29 Apr 2023.